The Progressive Line

Imagine a company with an amazing CEO which has lead said company for the past year with such vision and enthusiasm that profits have doubled and stocks are worth more than ever before. Now imagine that same company holding a board meeting and voting to replace this same CEO with the president. The CEO did a great job, in fact he saved the company from having to close it’s doors. He loved his job and wouldn’t mind continuing to serve the company, however his time is up. Sure, everyone recognizes that the president is nowhere as capable as the outgoing CEO but a year has passed and this is how it has always been done.

What would people say about such a company that operates in this manner? Would people want to invest time and money with it? Could it even be expected to survive for very long?

Of course, as Freemasons we do this all the time. Once a year we assemble in our lodges and vote to move the Worshipful Master out of his seat and place the Senior Warden in the East, often without a lot of serious consideration about the consequences of such an action because “it’s always been that way”.

In times when many masons, lodges, and Grand Lodges are concerned about membership numbers and the longevity of our fraternity as a whole, why do we simply shrug out shoulders and give so little thought to who ends up in the most powerful position of any masonic lodge?

I believe the progressive line does serve a purpose: to train and prepare brethren for leadership positions in the lodge while giving the other members ample time to determine if a brother is, or will ever become, leadership material. Just as we have to be physically qualified to be made masons, so should brethren be mentally qualified to become leaders.

Many masons can recall lodges which were once healthy and thriving yet fell into a terrible condition within a short amount of time. How many times, I wonder, can these hard times a lodge faces be attributed to poor leadership? Take a lodge which has been successful, be it one, two, five, or ten years, and dump an incompetent Worshipful Master in the East and all watch as all the hard work and effort of those that came before stops bearing fruit.

So, in closing, I don’t believe the progressive line is a bad concept. In fact, when properly utilized it serves the important function of preparing masons for eventual leadership of the lodge if they prove they are capable. Sadly however, there seems to be a sort of apathy regarding the progressive line in many lodges. Many brethren get elected to the East whom few brethren believe are, or will ever be, capable of serious leadership. Still other brethren elect someone to the East thinking or hoping that putting a hat on the man will mold him into a capable leader in some sort of trial by fire.

If we want our fraternity to grow,  even thrive, in the future then we must seriously reevaluate the progressive line in our lodges and reconsider how it is being implemented in our lodges. Is it providing opportunities and experience needed for brethren to grow as leaders? Or, is it serving as a conveyor belt for officers, pushing them closer and closer to their final destination in the East without any thought or consideration?

This entry was posted in Freemasonry, Running A Masonic Lodge. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to The Progressive Line

  1. James says:

    When a lodge has been well led it often feels like a let down when the new and inexperienced Master takes over.
    In 2 of my current lodges the Master and Wardens having reached the end of their terms are really only just getting the hang of their work. In one of the lodges the Master and Wardens have never done a full closing of the 3rd – with the Wardens taking to the floor for a demonstration of the secrets.
    Where a lodge is only meeting monthly I would prefer 2 year terms.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Jon says:

    James- what Jurisdiction are you from? ive sat in lodges in several states and never seen the wardens “taking to the floor” at closing

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Jon says:

    Hmm that’s interesting…id like too see that some day…by secrets do you mean signs?

    Liked by 1 person

    • James says:

      In various Scottish rituals the JW comes to the South and the SW to the North and the JW advances progressing through EA signs, pass grip and pw, FC signs, pass grip and pw and then MM signs and FPoF (silently) and then the SW goes to the E and says: RWM deign to receive from me the substitute secrets of a MM. The RWM descends to the floor and to receive them as before.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: How Freemasonry Is (Or Used To Be) An Honor Group – lonestarmason

  5. Pingback: My Response to ’10 Propositions For Texas Freemasonry’ | The Lone Star Mason

  6. Corbin L Douthitt says:

    Wow! some great ideas and responses here!! ‘ A Progressive Line” CAN work IF and ONLY if the senior officers and old guys are TEACHING the new officers about their duties AND they are passing on what is going on in the last year. The W:M: may have many things going on that the jr officers are NOT privy to- which leads to re-inventing the wheel each year and little to no growth. There MUST be a passing along of information- even as mundane as the combination to the lodge safe so that it doesn’t get drilled out!- instead of ASKING some ‘old folks’ if they know the combination!. Communication is imperative. Teaching and showing the officer behind you is courteous and necessary!! In my lodge, in the old days- being SD didn’t mean you went to the South, nor did being in the South mean you went to the West!! you were being observed as to your level of commitment, interest in the work and your attitude! If the brothers saw something that they didn’t believe was good for the Lodge- you got left behind. SOME learned from it and advanced later. Others just walked away- seldom missed. Freemasonry MUST adapt to the new generations. I really enjoy these articles!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Pingback: 8 Ways To Improve Your Lodge In 2019 | Masonic Improvement

  8. Pingback: Chaos In The Quarries – Know Your Role | Masonic Improvement

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s